jueves, 21 de julio de 2022

The jealous engineer problem

 


One day Tony woke up and didn't find his wife in the house.

— Where were you?

— I wanted to work out and just walked around the block. Look at my pedometer.

— What distance does the pedometer show?

—  Really Tony? again with your jealousy?

Angry, Tony snatches the pedometer from her and he read a distance traveled of $805$ meters.

— How many laps did you do?

— One lap!

— East or North?

 — Are you serious, Tony?

— East or North?

— East!

Tony had been the engineer in charge of paving the block years ago, and he knew that the four streets that made up the block were the same distance from the church where he married his wife. In addition, he remembered that the corners formed the following sequence of angles until he got back to his house: $60°$, $135°$, $85°$, $80°$ and that if his wife went east she must have traveled $200$ meters on the first street before to reach the $60°$- corner, a distance that he also remembered perfectly.

Was the wife lying? Justify your answer.

El problema del ingeniero celoso



Un día, Tony se despertó y no encontró a su esposa en la casa.

— ¿Dónde estabas?

— Quería ejercitarme y solo recorrí la cuadra. Mira mi podómetro.

— ¿Qué distancia marca el podómetro?

— ¿En serio, Tony? ¿otra vez con tus celos?

Airado, Tony le arrebata el podómetro y lee una distancia recorrida de $805$ metros.

— ¿Cuántas vueltas diste?

— ¡Una! ¡una vuelta!

— ¿Este o norte?

— ¿Hablas en serio, Tony?

— ¿Este o norte?

— ¡Este!

Tony había sido el ingeniero a cargo del asfaltado de la cuadra años atrás y sabía que las cuatro calles que formaban la cuadra estaban a la misma distancia de la iglesia donde se casó con su esposa. Además, recordaba que las esquinas formaban la siguiente secuencia de ángulos hasta llegar de vuelta a su casa: $60°$, $135°$, $85°$, $80°$ y que si su esposa partió hacia el este debió haber recorrido $200$ metros en la primera calle antes de llegar a la esquina de $60°$, distancia que también recordaba a la perfección. 

¿Mentía la esposa? Justifica tu respuesta.

domingo, 10 de julio de 2022

A generalization of Lami's theorem for 4 forces

 In physics, Lami's theorem is an equation relating the magnitudes of three coplanar, concurrent and non-collinear vectors, which keeps an object in static equilibrium, with the angles directly opposite to the corresponding vectors. According to the theorem

$$\frac{F_1}{\sin{\alpha}}=\frac{F_2}{\sin{\beta}}=\frac{F_3}{\sin{\gamma}}.\tag{1}$$

where $F_1$, $F_2$ and $F_3$ are the magnitudes of the three coplanar, concurrent and non-collinear vectors which keep the object in static equilibrium, and $\alpha$, $\beta$ and $\gamma$ are the angles directly opposite to the vectors (see Figure 1).

Figure 1. $\alpha$, $\beta$ and $\gamma$ are the angles directly opposite to the vectors $F_1$, $F_2$ and $F_3$

Lami's theorem is applied in static analysis of mechanical and structural systems. The theorem is named after Bernard Lamy. The proof of Lami's theorem is essentially based on the law of sines.

On the Internet there are hundreds of static equilibrium problems where they apply Lami's theorem to a three-force system, see for instance Dubey - Engineering Mechanics: Statics and Dynamics, section 3.10. Although Dubey's book is recent (2013) there is not a single equilibrium problem based on a four-force system. Coincidentally, the author of this note has come across questions on the Internet questioning the possibility of applying Lami's theorem for more than three forces. In this note we give a generalization of Lami's theorem for four forces.

Theorem 1 (Generalization). If four coplanar, concurrent and non-collinear forces act upon an object, and the object remains in static equilibrium, then

Figure 2. An example of the situation described in the theorem 1. 


$$AD\sin{\alpha'}+BC\sin{\gamma'}=AB\sin{\beta'}+CD\sin{\delta'}.\tag{2}$$

where $A$, $B$, $C$ and $D$ are the magnitudes of the four vectors and $\alpha'$, $\beta'$, $\gamma'$ and $\delta'$ are the angles between them (see Figure 2).

Proof. Consider the quadrilateral formed by the four vectors in such a manner that the head of one touches the tail of another (see Figure 3) and denote $\Delta$ its area. If $\alpha$, $\beta$, $\gamma$ and $\delta$ are the interior angles of the quadrilateral, then its area can be written as

Figure 3. Notice that if $\alpha$, $\beta$, $\gamma$ and $\delta$ are the interior angles of the quadrilateral formed by the four vectors, then $\alpha$ and $\alpha'$ are supplementary and similarly for $\beta'$, $\gamma'$ and $\delta'$

$$\Delta=\frac12AD\sin{\alpha}+\frac12BC\sin{\gamma}=\frac12AB\sin{\beta}+\frac12CD\sin{\delta}$$ 
and as $\sin{\alpha'}=\sin{(\pi-\alpha)}=\sin{\alpha}$, and similarly for $\beta'$, $\gamma'$ and $\delta'$, the relation in $(2)$ follows.

$\square$

Theorem 1 is a generalization in the sense that if one of the vectors vanishes, the relation we obtain is that of Lami's theorem. Indeed, for instance suppose $C=0$, then the relation $(2)$ reduces to
$$D\sin{\alpha'}=B\sin{\beta'},$$
which is Lami's theorem.

Remark. A generalization of Lami's theorem is given by H. Shekhar. However, this generalization is different since it only considers cyclic polygons with an odd number of sides.

lunes, 27 de junio de 2022

A generalization of the Pythagorean trigonometric identity

"Discovery is seeing what everybody else has seen, and thinking what nobody else has thought."

-- Albert Szent-Györgyi (1893 - 1986)

I don't know how I missed it, but the Pythagorean trigonometric identity is a special case of the generalized half-angle formulas. 

The following is a generalization of the half-angle formulas for a triangle.

Generalization. Let $a$, $b$, $c$, $d$ be the sides of a general convex quadrilateral, $s$ is the semiperimeter, and  $\alpha$ and $\gamma$ are opposite angles, then

$$ad\sin^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}+bc\cos^2{\frac{\gamma}{2}}=(s-a)(s-d).\tag{1}$$

For a proof of $(1)$ see pp. 8 in MATINF.

The Pythagorean identity as a special case

 In $(1)$, consider the case when $a=c$, $b=d$ and $\alpha=\gamma$ so that the quadrilateral is a parallelogram . Then

$$ab\sin^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}+ab\cos^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=\frac{-a+b+c+d}{2}\cdot{\frac{a+b+c-d}{2}}=ab.$$

Dividing both sides by $ab$ you get

$$\sin^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}+\cos^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=1.$$


Or by making $\frac{\alpha}{2}=\theta$,

$$\sin^2{\theta}+\cos^2{\theta}=1,$$

which is the Pythagorean trigonometric identity.

An interesting discussion about this generalization is available at MathSE.

For more implications of $(1)$ I invite you to see The theoretical importance of the half-angle formulas.

sábado, 25 de junio de 2022

Another proof of Euler inequality via the half-angle formulas

The Euler's inequality is an immediate consequence of Euler's identity in a triangle,
$$OI^2=R^2−2Rr.$$
An additional proof of Euler's inequality is given at Elias Lampakis, Am Math Monthly, 122 (9), November 2015, p 892. Now, continuing with this madness of proving everything from the half-angle formulas, we give an alternative proof of Euler's inequality.

Theorem (Euler): If $R$ and $r$ are the circumradius and, respectively, the inradius of a triangle, then
$$R\geq2r.\tag{1}$$

Proof. Let $a$, $b$ and $c$ be the sides of $\triangle{ABC}$. Denote $s$ its semiperimeter and $\angle{BAC}=\alpha$. It is easy to show that 
$$(s-a)\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=r.\tag{2}$$
Also, it is well-known that
$$\frac{abc}{4\Delta}=R\qquad and \qquad\Delta=\frac{bc\sin{\alpha}}{2},\tag{3}$$
where $\Delta$ is the area of $\triangle{ABC}$. Substituting $(2)$ and $(3)$ in $(1)$ we have
$$\begin{aligned}\frac{abc}{4\Delta}&\geq(-a+b+c)\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\\\frac{abc}{4bc\sin{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\cos{\frac{\alpha}{2}}}&\geq(-a+b+c)\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\\abc&\geq(-a+b+c)(4bc\sin^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}})\\abc&\geq(-a+b+c)(a-b+c)(a+b-c)\end{aligned}$$
This is Padoa's inequality, so the proof is complete.

domingo, 19 de junio de 2022

$\sum_{cyc}\tan\frac\alpha2\tan\frac\beta2\geq4$ for a cyclic quadrilateral

 Let $ABCD$ be a cyclic quadrilateral with sides $a$, $b$, $c$ and $d$. Denote $s$ the semiperimeter and let $\angle{DAB}=\alpha$, $\angle{ABC}=\beta$, $\angle{BCD}=\gamma$ and $\angle{CDA}=\delta$. Then the following inequality holds

$$\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\geq4.\tag{1}$$

Proof. Substituting from the half-angle formula for the tangent we have that
$$\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}=\sqrt{\frac{(s-a)(s-d)}{(s-b)(s-c)}}\cdot{\sqrt{\frac{(s-a)(s-b)}{(s-c)(s-d)}}}=\frac{s-a}{s-c}.$$
Similarly, 
$$\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}=\frac{s-b}{s-d}\qquad\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}=\frac{s-c}{s-a}\qquad\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=\frac{s-d}{s-b}$$
Thus, the left-hand side of $(1)$ can be rewritten as follows
$$\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=\frac{s-a}{s-c}+\frac{s-b}{s-d}+\frac{s-c}{s-a}+\frac{s-d}{s-b}.$$
But, 
$$\frac{s-a}{s-c}+\frac{s-b}{s-d}+\frac{s-c}{s-a}+\frac{s-d}{s-b}=\frac{a-c}{s-a}+\frac{b-d}{s-b}+\frac{c-a}{s-c}+\frac{d-b}{s-d}+4.\tag{2}$$
Since $\frac{a-c}{s-a}+\frac{c-a}{s-c}=\frac{4(a-c)^2}{(-a+b+c+d)(a+b-c+d)}$, and similarly for $\frac{b-d}{s-b}+\frac{d-b}{s-d}$, then $\frac{a-c}{s-a}+\frac{b-d}{s-b}+\frac{c-a}{s-c}+\frac{d-b}{s-d}$ is positive. Hence,
$$\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\geq4.$$
$\square$
Notice equality holds when $ABCD$ is rectangular. 

From $(2)$ it also follows that

$$\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\delta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}>\frac{a-c}{s-a}-\frac{a-c}{s-c}+\frac{b-d}{s-b}-\frac{ b-d}{s-d}.$$

A huge list of inequalities can be seen at Cut-the-knot.org.

lunes, 23 de mayo de 2022

The theoretical importance of half-angle formulas

"The scientific principles that man employs to obtain the foreknowledge of an eclipse, or of any thing else relating to the motion of the heavenly bodies, are contained chiefly in that part of science that is called trigonometry, or the properties of a triangle, which, when applied to the study of the heavenly bodies, is called astronomy; when applied to direct the course of a ship on the ocean, it is called navigation; when applied to the construction of figures drawn by a ruler and compass, it is called geometry; when applied to the construction of plans of edifices, it is called architecture; when applied to the measurement of any portion of the surface of the earth, it is called land-surveying. In fine, it is the soul of science. It is an eternal truth: it contains the mathematical demonstration of which man speaks, and the extent of its uses are unknown." —Thomas Paine 

Unlike the laws of sines, cosines and tangents, which are very well known, the half-angle formulas seem (although they appear timidly in the mathematical literature) not to enjoy the same popularity. Thus, while there are entire chapters devoted to the law of sines, cosines, and tangents and their applications, there is not even a Wikipedia article on half-angle formulas. Right now you may be imagining this version of the half angle formulas

$$\sin{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=\pm\sqrt{\frac{1-\cos{\alpha}}{2}}\qquad\qquad\cos{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=\pm\sqrt{\frac{1+\cos{\alpha}}{2}},$$

that do appear in the textbooks of the first trigonometry courses (at least with the one I studied). But actually I mean these

$$\sin^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}} = \frac{(s-b)(s-c)}{bc}\qquad\qquad\cos^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}= \frac{s(s-a)}{bc},\tag{1}$$ 

where $a$, $b$, and $c$ are the sides of a triangle, $\alpha$ is the angle opposite side $a$, and $s$ is the semiperimeter. I found the furthest reference to these formulas in a conversation posted online between Conway and Doyle, where Conway uses them to prove Heron's formula and later claims to have taken it from a sequel by Casey.

I discovered $(1)$ independently trying to prove the law of cosines by contradiction. When I realized that they were known, I tried to generalize them and I got this

$$\sin^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=\frac{(s-a)(s-d)}{ad+bc}\qquad\qquad \cos^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=\frac{(s-b)(s-c)}{ad+bc},\tag{2}$$

where $a$, $b$, $c$ and $d$ are the sides of a cyclic quadrilateral, $s$ is semiperimeter and $\angle{DAB}=\alpha$.

Before discovering the conversation between Conway and Doyle, I had been excited that I had found an original proof of Heron's formula using $(1)$. When I found $(2)$, I thought that by analogous reasoning I could prove Brahmagupta's formula. So it was. But in a geometry forum someone referred me to an ancient Greek book that contained $(2)$. I then sent my proof of Brahmagupta's formula to Martin Josefsson who referred me to Casey's book "A Treatise On Plane Trigonometry" where my proof already appeared. But I didn't give up and tried to generalize $(2)$ getting this

$$ad\sin^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}+bc\cos^2{\frac{\gamma}{2}}=(s-a)(s-d)\qquad\qquad bc\sin^2{\frac{\gamma}{2}}+ad\cos^2{\frac{\alpha}{2}}=(s-b)(s-c),\tag{3}$$

where $a$, $b$, $c$ and $d$ are the sides of a general quadrilateral, $s$ is semiperimeter, $\angle{DAB}=\alpha$ and $\angle{BCD}=\gamma$. Surprisingly, $(3)$ also generalizes the Pythagorean identity! Take a look at GeoDom - A generalization of the Pythagorean trigonometric identity.

Bretschneider's formula is known to be a generalization of Heron's and Brahmagupta's formulas. Naturally, I wondered if I could generalize Casey's proof of Brahmagupta's formula using $(3)$ and thus derive Bretschneider's formula. And I did it. I sent my formulas in $(3)$ and my proof of the Bretschneider's formula to Josefsson (among many other mathematicians) and he told me this:

"I like your paper, especially how you put these important formulas in a single framwork. I cannot say that I remember seeing the identities (4) and (5) anywhere else before."

Where identities (4) and (5) are the identities $(3)$ in this post.

And then he said:

"Even though much has already been written about these formulas, the ideas for proving Bretschneider' formula and the area of a bicentric quadrilateral are novel as far as I know. I hope you get your paper published."

I decided to write an article about these formulas called "Two Identities and their Consequences" which was published in MATINF.

In almost three years of exploring possible applications of $(1, 2, 3)$, this is what I have found:

Using $(1, 2)$ we can also derive (you can see most of the proofs here):

  •  The law of cosines
  •  The law of sines
  •  The law of tangents
  •  Stewart's theorem
  •  Compound angle formulas
  •  Mollweide's formula
  •  The product $AI\cdot{BI}\cdot{CI}$
  •  The bisector length formula
  •  Mahavira's formulas
  •  Zelich's lemma
  • Euler's triangle inequality
  • Yun’s Inequality (Josefsson)

Other unnamed identities and inequalities:

  •  $\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}+\tan{\frac{\beta}{2}}\tan{\frac{\gamma}{2}}=1$
  •  $r=4R\sin{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\sin{\frac{\beta}{2}}\sin{\frac{\gamma}{2}}$
  •  $s=4R\cos{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\cos{\frac{\beta}{2}}\cos{\frac{\gamma}{2}}$
  • $\sin{\frac{\alpha}{2}}\sin{\frac{\beta}{2}}\sin{\frac{\gamma}{2}}\le\frac{1}{8}$
  • $\sum_{cyc}\tan\frac\alpha2\tan\frac\beta2\geq4$ for a cyclic quadrilateral
  • I could go on...

The formulas $(1, 2, 3)$ explain the Heron-Brahmagupta-Bretschneider development better than I have seen anywhere else. This made me wonder what would happen if I analogously applied the half-angle formulas to formulas where half-angles explicitly appeared, such as Mollweide's (rather Newton's) formula or the law of tangents. This is how these generalizations arose:

When questioning Martin Josefsson about the originality of these generalizations, this is what he said:

"As far as I can recall, I have not seen any of them, at least not in modern books or papers, and even if some of them where to be found in an old text, they are at least not well known, and deserve to be wider known."

And Alexander Mednykh said:

"I never saw these results before. Certainly, it is interesting to find a no-Euclidean generalization of these results."

Apart from the proof of the Bretschneider's formula, I haven't found any other applications for $(3)$.

Interestingly, half angles seem to be everywhere: from circle angle theorems to the Weierstrass substitution in Integral Calculus. Even when Viète derived his formula for $\pi$ using an infinite product, he started by writing $\sin{x}=2\sin{\frac12x}\cos{\frac12x}$.

Some comments:

Thibaut Demaerel, from Leuven University, commented:


Check out the details of his proof at MathSE.

Dr. James Cook commented at Math Educators SE (where due to the controversy that my publication generated I decided to delete it):


Related material